Collector Car Market: 5 Ways to Win More Business

19 August 2025

In the August 20, 2025 episode of The Accelerator, Vice President of Automotive Intelligence at Hagerty, Brian Rebold, highlights recent collector car market fluctuations and what’s driving them. The Accelerator is a Hagerty podcast featuring news and discussions around collector car insurance, Hagerty products, enthusiast culture, and more. 

Like any market, the classic and collector vehicle market has fluctuated over the years. In recent history, there was the sleepy pre-2019 pace, the pandemic-fueled boom, and then a leveling out to a more stable, predictable environment.

On this episode of The Accelerator, Brian Rabold highlights recent market fluctuations and what’s driving them. Rabold, vice president of automotive intelligence at Hagerty, also offers tips on how to use market data to win more business and better serve your enthusiast clients, even if you haven’t identified them yet. 

Here are his top tips:

1. Review values annually

  • Every Hagerty policy comes with Guaranteed Value®, ensuring clients will be paid what their car is worth in the event of a total loss. Keeping your clients’ values up to date is essential for making sure this benefit works the way it should. 
  • Log in and use Hagerty Valuation Tools® on hagertyagent.com at least annually at renewal to check that coverage is accurate. This results in happier clients and reduced E&O exposure. 

2. Prompt your clients: “Tell me about your cars”

  • Extra or “fun” cars are often an enthusiast's pride and joy.
  • If they light up when you ask about their cars, that’s your cue to start a Hagerty conversation.

3. Think beyond typical “classics”

  • The definition of a classic car has changed, and today’s market includes ’80s–2000s performance cars, rare-spec trucks, and 1990s icons like the Mazda Miata.
  • Cars like these are often undervalued or underinsured with the wrong carrier. If your client has a classic car, no matter what year it’s from, make sure it’s properly protected. 

4. Keep an eye on the next generation

  • Millennials and Gen Z are buying enthusiast vehicles, across the year, make, and model spectrum, from vintage muscle to modern sports cars driven by nostalgia, pop culture, and social media trends.
  • Enthusiast car culture isn't dying, it’s evolving as younger generations drive and collect cars that are meaningful to them. Talk to your younger clients about the cars they’re most excited about. 

5. Use Hagerty’s market expertise

  • Hagerty has been in the specialty insurance industry since 1984—we have experts on staff who are watching, analyzing, and reporting on the market. 
  • Leverage valuation tools, book and collection reviews, and the Hagerty Insider to stay ahead of trends and spark client conversations.

Bottom line: Classic and collector vehicles aren’t a niche interest—they’re everywhere. Ask the right questions, keep values current, and use Hagerty’s tools to turn those insights into growth. Hagerty, Guaranteed Value, and Hagerty Valuation Tools are registered trademarks of The Hagerty Group LLC, ©2026 The Hagerty Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The Hagerty Group, LLC is a subsidiary of Hagerty, Inc.

Hagerty, Guaranteed Value, and Hagerty Valuation Tools are registered trademarks of The Hagerty Group LLC, ©2025 The Hagerty Group, LLC. All Rights Reserved. The Hagerty Group, LLC is a subsidiary of Hagerty, Inc.